Gina Vivinetto’s Greatest Hits

Yes, David Sedaris makes stuff up. Deal with it.

In the ongoing public flagellation of memoir writers, humorist David Sedaris is the latest author to come under scrutiny for the vaidilty of his writing. Are Sedaris’s stories “real”? The New Republic wanted to know last March when the magazine accused him of exaggerating the truth to – gasp! – make a funny.

Well, duh. Anyone of reasonable intelligence who has sat down with one of Sedaris’s hilarious but not entirely probable stories has the understanding that the author, who by all accounts does come from a wacky family, nevertheless delves into far fledge territory. It’s called creative license, Oprah.

In a recent interview with Mother Jones, Sedaris happily chats about his writing and its truthfulness.

Q: So, do you exaggerate?

A: Boy, do I. And if it weren’t for The New Yorker fact-checkers, I’d do it more. I’ve always been up front about that. I think that was what was weird to me about it, was this idea that I had somehow been caught. I had written [in The New Yorker] that my spiders got so obese that their legs started chafing. I talked to the spider expert at the natural history museum, and he said that spiders’ legs never rub together. I said, “No, I know they wouldn’t. I’m just saying it as a joke.” I don’t know how easy [The New Republic] thinks it is to make shit up. To say that a humorist exaggerates to get big laughs, I don’t see how that’s big news.

So, add Sedaris to the list of writers, including Augusten Burroughs and James Frey who knows how to spin a yarn. As for the subject of boyfriend Hugh,, Sedaris told the magazine he lies about him, too:

If there’s any guy standing behind me people will say, “Is that Hugh?” And I’m like, ‘Do you think he has nothing better to do than to travel around with me and stand behind me while I sign books?’ One time, though, there was a beefy Puerto Rican security guy, very stern and very tough, so I told everybody that was Hugh. I could see how irritating that was for him, because here’s everybody thinking that he’s gay and that he’s my boyfriend. But his job was to protect me, not to kill me. So there was nothing he could do about it.

Are you a fan of Sedaris? Have you been to a reading?

Single Post Navigation

5 thoughts on “Yes, David Sedaris makes stuff up. Deal with it.

  1. marabeth on said:

    Yes, I am a huge fan, yes I went to reading in Mpls. What does Oprah say about him? She is really not that smart.

  2. Liset on said:

    I love Sedaris. He lightened up many moments of my life in Cuba, I smiled and laughed out loud with his stories in times I really needed it.
    I don’t care if he exaggerates or makes things up, that is such a stupid thing to take into account that won’t even comment on it.

    I’m going to see him today!!!!

  3. Liset on said:

    btw: He was AWESOME. Extremely funny with that intelligent humor of his.

    I love the guy. I can’t care less about some things he does or doesn’t do.


  4. chris on said:

    He exaggerates stuff, hmmm, read the bible, now that is exaggerating stuff.

    but more importantly what about Gene Sheapard, a favorite funny man raconteur of days gone by. He would never exaggerate. Or King George Bush II, he and Condeleza and the rest of the republican happiness wouls never ever exaggerate anything , so as to like invade a country.

    no no no lets whip Mr Ssodaris over this, no wait he might like that.


    get over it

  5. dufmanno on said:

    Love Sedaris, everyone who’s not as good likes to crap on his parade. Like you said , it’s not news that some of it is exaggerated. As long as I’m laughing, I could care less.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: